Security News

UK Tribunal Confirms Government Secretly Ordered Apple to Keep Access to iCloud Data

The Record · 20 Nov 2026 · updated 21 Nov 2026
Key Takeaway If your business or staff in the UK relied on iCloud's Advanced Data Protection, assume that data is no longer protected by keys only the user holds, and review what sensitive information is stored there.

The Investigatory Powers Tribunal, the only UK court able to hear certain national security cases, has confirmed that the British government served Apple with a secret legal notice aimed at the encryption protecting iCloud accounts. The judgment ends almost two years of official refusal to acknowledge what had been widely reported.

The three judges stated that the government "has given Apple a technical capability notice". This is the legal power used to demand that Apple keep the ability to access the content of iCloud accounts. The tribunal rejected the government's "neither confirm nor deny" policy, which argued that even confirming the notice would harm national security. It noted that public comments by senior U.S. politicians and British media reports citing officials had already pointed to the notice's existence. According to The Register, the judges also concluded that some media briefings had been authorised by the UK government, and the notice is issued under the Investigatory Powers Act 2016.

The dispute centres on Apple's Advanced Data Protection (ADP) feature. ADP keeps encryption keys on users' own devices rather than Apple's servers, so Apple cannot access iCloud content even when served with a lawful request. Last February, Apple withdrew ADP for British users entirely after receiving the notice. According to The Register, the story broke in February 2025 when The Washington Post reported the demand. It adds that without ADP the data is still encrypted but Apple holds the keys, that some categories stay end-to-end encrypted regardless, and that ADP remains available in the US. The notice's details are not public.

According to The Register, in August 2025 then-US director of national intelligence Tulsi Gabbard said the UK had agreed to drop its demand for access to Americans' encrypted data, and the Financial Times later reported that the UK replaced its original notice with one focused on British users.

The ruling does not decide whether the notice is lawful. A substantive hearing is scheduled for the first half of 2027. The Register reports that the judges agreed disclosing all the material would harm national security, but that some could be released once the boundaries are practical to set. It also says Apple's first challenge was dismissed after a change in circumstances, that it filed a second claim in July 2026, and that Liberty, Privacy International and two individuals are bringing a separate challenge. The Register says the government states the powers have strict safeguards and that it never has direct access to company systems or data. Our original report noted that a government spokesperson did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

Why it matters

Any organisation with UK-based staff, clients or devices that assumed iCloud backups were end-to-end protected now has a gap: ADP is withdrawn for British users, so Apple can again technically reach that content. A vendor's encryption promise can be changed by legal order, and the change may not be disclosed. Security leaders should treat cloud encryption features as dependent on the jurisdiction they operate in when classifying data.

What to do

  • Identify staff, clients and devices in the UK that rely on iCloud backups.
  • Reclassify data stored in iCloud for UK users on the assumption that Apple holds the keys.
  • Move sensitive material to storage with keys you control where jurisdictional access is a concern.
  • Monitor the 2027 substantive hearing and any Apple changes to ADP availability.
Apple iCloud encryption UK privacy Advanced Data Protection
Also reported by The Register

Summarised by CISO AI from The Record, with the same story also reported by The Register, written with Claude Sonnet 5.5. We link back to every original so you can read it yourself.