UK Audit Office: Risk Teams Are Growing, but Still Sidelined in Key Decisions
The number of chief risk officers in UK government has more than doubled over the past decade, but most risk professionals in Whitehall believe they lack influence. That is the central finding of a National Audit Office (NAO) report, Risk management in government: improving capability and decision making, published on November 18.
The NAO said 58% of the risk professionals it polled are typically brought in too late to shape decisions. It found limited evidence that major decisions or organisational direction changed because of their input. The low seniority of many risk leads can also limit their access to senior decision-making forums.
Cyber risk is a particular weak spot. The report found that skills gaps among members of Audit and Risk Assurance Committees in areas such as cybersecurity constrain their ability to advise and challenge boards. Leaders do not always understand the cyber risks in their risk registers or see how they link to strategic objectives. Many departments define a risk appetite, but fewer than half (47%) said it actually informs decisions, and most reported that the majority of their principal risks sat outside their stated tolerance. The NAO pointed to legacy technology and specialist staff shortages as obstacles to bringing cyber risks within appetite.
The result is that known risks are not always dealt with promptly. The British Library had identified risks from growing third-party access to its IT systems, but was breached before planned changes were put in place. The NAO urged a continuous approach to risk monitoring, with risk registers that are robust, living documents. Its head, Gareth Davies, said government must put risk management at the heart of how it plans, spends and delivers.
Why it matters
The failure here is not missing risk registers but a gap between identifying risk and acting on it: a risk appetite that rarely informs decisions, and risk staff consulted after choices are made. The British Library example shows the cost, as a known third-party access risk was breached before the fix landed. Any organisation with a register no one is accountable for acting on, including small businesses, is exposed to the same pattern.
What to do
- Review your risk register and remove or update stale entries so it reflects current significant risks.
- Bring the person responsible for cyber risk into planning for new systems and suppliers before decisions are made.
- Check whether your top risks sit outside your stated tolerance and assign an owner and deadline to each.
- Prioritise fixes for known risks from third-party access to your IT systems.