Industry News

Ransom Negotiators Under Scrutiny as US Investigators Probe Links to ShinyHunters Extortion

Krebs on Security · 19 Oct 2026
Key Takeaway If you use an outside negotiator or incident response firm after a breach, check who they are, what they must disclose to you and to law enforcement, and keep authorities involved from the start.

US federal investigators pursuing the ShinyHunters hacking group have identified executives at two ransomware negotiation firms who allegedly kept unusually close relations with the extortion gang, according to Krebs on Security. Sources say one US-based executive may have helped operate a website that pressured victims to pay. The executive and firm have not been named because no charges have been laid.

The probe gathered pace after ShinyHunters hacked the FBI recruitment site fbijobs.gov in late September and threatened to publish the stolen files, which reportedly included medical records, Social Security numbers and home addresses. Dutch police arrested suspected member Pepijn van der Stap on 15 September 2026 while he was logged into Signal, giving investigators access to recent chats. Reuters reported that the group's current leader, a teenager known as Rey, was detained in Jordan and is cooperating with the FBI.

Those messages reportedly showed frequent contact between Van der Stap and Canadian executive Edward Dubrovsky, who was arrested and charged with threatening to disclose stolen data and interfering with interstate commerce. A source says the chats indicate he knew the FBI data had been stolen and did not tell the bureau before the public threat. Executives were also said to learn of new victims before the victims knew they had been breached.

Investigators also believe an executive at a large US consulting firm played an active role in running the now-defunct Shinywire extortion site. It was live from about 3 May to 16 October 2026 and listed nearly 100 victims, each urged to negotiate and shown samples of stolen files. Victims who ignored the demands for seven days saw their data published on a Tor-based leak blog. The FBI says ShinyHunters has extorted more than $70 million this year.

Why it matters

Many businesses assume a negotiator is a neutral expert acting only in the victim's interest. Reports that negotiators spoke with the attackers and knew of victims before the victims did challenge that trust, and they raise confidentiality and conflict-of-interest risks for any firm that shares breach details with a third party. Security leaders now need to treat negotiator vetting and contract terms as part of incident response planning.

What to do

  • Ask any ransom negotiation or response firm to disclose in writing its past contact with extortion groups and any conflicts of interest.
  • Add contract terms requiring prompt reporting of breaches and limiting how your incident data is shared.
  • Report any extortion demand to law enforcement rather than relying only on a third party.
  • Check phishing defences and credential protections, since the Intuitive Surgical breach began with a targeted phishing email.

Summarised by CISO AI from Krebs on Security, written with Claude Sonnet 5.5. We link back to every original so you can read it yourself.