New Voluntary Guidelines Target the Commercial Spyware Industry, but Advocates Say They Fall Short
The United States this week signed onto an international set of voluntary industry guidelines for commercial cyber intrusion capabilities, a category that includes spyware. The guidelines are the second step in the Pall Mall Process, an initiative led by the UK and France, and follow last year's code for nations. The two foreign ministries said the aim is to discourage irresponsible activity in the market, improve transparency for regulators, vendors and customers, and give clarity to businesses working in or near the industry.
The guidelines rest on four pillars: compliance with regulations and norms, due diligence, risk management and monitoring of compliance. Recommendations include following export controls, creating a risk assessment process, applying technical access controls such as encryption, and continuously observing who can use the tools.
Some advocates say the result is a compromise that does not go far enough. Natalia Krapiva of Access Now said civil society had pushed for mandatory technical kill switches, more transparency and stronger due diligence, but will keep working with the process. Gayatri Khandhadai of the Business and Human Rights Centre said the outcome falls short of what is needed to hold the industry to account, and that there is little evidence spyware companies meet even their minimum responsibilities under international human rights law.